Failure rate of modern PC motherboards?
Matthew Barrera 
I recently had a motherboard fail on me. If I add my experience with motherboards of desktops, laptops and servers, I've probably been responsible for about 50-60 years of motherboard use (most in a desktop environment). The failure I experienced was in a server that ran 24/7 for the past 24 months (new machine in 2008). Now I've been in the biz for about 20 years, so some of the 'long life' motherboards were using 1990s technology.
Can anyone comment on whether a 50 year mean time between failures (MTBF) is fairly typical for all motherboards that are not DOA? Especially, given 2010 manufacturing/quality techniques. Assume that the motherboards operate in typical humidity ranges in office environments that typically don't exceed 85 degrees F, and are not subjected to high shock or dust conditions, and have proper AC current conditioning and over-voltage protection. What should be expected for consumer grade motherboards for MTBF?
Incidentally, I have a server that is 2001 vintage -- I should be good for another 20+ years, right? Plus, then I can sell at auction for $10,000 in 2030 ;)
2 Answers
Capacitors. It's all about the capacitors.
They seem to be the first thing to go on motherboards, and an old psu with a 12v rail that flickers between 11 and 12.5v isn't going to live 50 years. If the motherobard has a good quality psu to go with it, and is kept at a steady cool temperature (so the electrolyte in the capacitors doesn't crystalise) the board will last to its full potential.
Also, am I right in thinking your MTBF calculation is likely to be skewed upwards if you're basing it off the use of multiple motherboards for short periods?
No single motherboard in your tests will reach its expected end-of-life, so you're only examining the left side of the failure rate "bell curve". To paraphrase, given you're ruling out DOA cases, running one motherboard for 50 years is going to be more likely to fail than running 50 motherboards for 1 year.
I would expect a MTBF of ~10 years.
3I haven't any specific numbers, but in general, the mean lifetime is well above the expected use. Considering computers are obsolete within just a few years, you can generally expect 10 years of life from some of the still parts. Hard drives, fans and power supplies have a somewhat shorter lifetime, but motherboards and in some cases memory can last quite a while.
20 years sounds a bit long to me, I personally haven't seen components running for that amount of time, but it might be possible if you get solid hardware and keep it in good conditions. I would suggest somewhere between 8-12 as the average maximum, though.
